6 Comments
Oct 30Liked by James J. Heaney

Your footnote (1) makes me wonder - is there actually any requirement that electors vote for a living person? Could they "execute their pledge" by simply voting for the dead person? This was a very real prospect in the 1790's, when it would've taken a substantial time for news of someone's death to reach far-off state capitals. I can easily imagine an alternate timeline where the frail George Washington died in late 1792 and got posthumous electoral votes.

In 1872, we actually did get three electors voting for a dead man (Horace Greeley, who had died between Election Day and the electoral college meeting) - but fortunately he'd lost the election, so that didn't matter. Now that I look it up, I see that Congress officially rejected their votes... but I'm not sure why.

Expand full comment
author

If you KNOW the guy is dead, I think you can't vote for him because he's no longer a qualified candidate. But you're right that I don't actually see a black-letter law to that effect, and, even if being dead does disqualify a candidate, it could be argued that the pledge legally overrides one's ordinary obligations? I don't know. Figuring this out might be an interesting blog post in itself.

All things considered: argh. States should fix this, and, meanwhile, presidents-elect should focus really hard on not dying until Inauguration Day (at which time they have my permission to die).

Expand full comment
Oct 30Liked by James J. Heaney

They don't even need to focus that long; after the Electoral College has voted, it's all clear per Section 3 of the 20th Amendment: "If, at the time fixed for the beginning of the term of the President, the President elect shall have died, the Vice President elect shall become President."

But yeah - argh. The states should fix the remaining gap (between Election Day and the Electoral College) that they themselves created by binding the electors.

Expand full comment
author

Ah, of course, how could I have forgotten! Thanks.

Expand full comment
Oct 31Liked by James J. Heaney

Ha! So many Heaney's present :D Doesn't your family have a past history as Deligates in bygone elections?

Expand full comment
author

My mom was a delegate to the 1992 Democratic National Convention in Madison Square Garden! (Then she was "escorted from the premises for her own safety" along with her delegation of pro-life Minnesota Democrats because the other Democrats really hated them and got physical about it.)

Expand full comment